Mark-Anthony Kaye was a product of the TFC Academy but after working his way up to TFC II for thier first season in USL in 2015 he would leave the cl;ub and sign for Louisville.
He joined LAFC in their inaugural 2018 season in MLS under current TFC coach Bob Bradley. He would go on to make 77 appearances for the club scoring 9 goals. In 2021 he was traded to Colorado for a hefty $1m in GAM and an international roster spot. He amassed 32 appearances and 4 goals for them in the 2021 and 2022 seasons.
He was signed by TFC in July 2022 in a deal that saw promising starlet Ralph Priso head the other way. The reds also had to drop (up to) $1.05m in GAM, an international roster spot, and the club's first-round draft pick in the 2023 draft to get him.